This was my second attempt, first time failed by around 20 points. I say "FINALLY" in the title because I've been at this for a couple years now, mostly held back by finances and having to take three attempts to pass ICND1, but I'm super hyped I finally got it after all this time and money. I also completed it in only 57 minutes, not that I was rushing but was just my natural pace of reading and finding the best answer.
Thanks to everyone who helped. I used Odom, GNS3, Boson Practice Exams (highly recommended, though some of their questions are outside the scope of the CCNA so don't be too intimidated by them), and this course on Udemy by Neil Anderson.
Edit: Obligatory thanks for the gold, kind stranger!