Press J to jump to the feed. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts
Sort by
Single comment thread. View all comments 
Colorado
3 points · 3 months ago

Does everyone just get dementia at the age of 70? I thought it was a disease that only some old people get.

Comment deleted3 months ago
Colorado
-3 points · 3 months ago

Yeah exactly! If your over 80 you still only have a 17% chance of getting dementia. Why would anyone approach a situation with such slim odds as though it's likely to occur?

Dementia isn't a black and white. Beyond that 17% a very significant amount will have significant degeneration that does not yet meet the threshold for a Dementia diagnosis.

Colorado
0 points · 3 months ago

Beyond that 17% a very significant amount will have significant degeneration that does not yet meet the threshold for a Dementia diagnosis.

You got a source on that?

Still seems like a possibility rather than a probability.

What, are you literally asking me if age-related cognitive decline and mild cognitive impairment exist?

Five seconds on google and you could have answered that for yourself.

https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/21491632

Prevalence of CI ranged from 4 to 70% depending on the impairment criteria used. Agreement between different criteria was poor to moderate. This lack of consistency had greatest impact on MCI subtype classifications with many being reclassified as “normal” or into a different subtype when stringency of the criteria was increased or decreased.

Colorado
0 points · 3 months ago · edited 3 months ago

What, are you literally asking me if age-related cognitive decline and mild cognitive impairment exist?

No that's a silly assumption. I wanted to see what the basis for this claim was:

Beyond that 17% a very significant amount will have significant degeneration that does not yet meet the threshold for a Dementia diagnosis.

4% to 70% of all subjects, and an undefined criteria for diagnosis doesn't seem like a "significant amount" of the remaining 83% and it doesn't suggest they have "significant degeneration"

Especially when the study was meant to look at the criteria used to disgnose CI, and especially when the conclusion is "The prevalence of CI was strongly affected by the choice of neuropsychological assessment parameters. Guidelines for operationalizing CI are required."

This is why I asked for your source, because it doesn't support your claim at all. You just guessed it up and then tried to find something that agrees with your guess. But you literally couldn't even do that. In-fucking-credible

Edit: where did you go?

Comment deleted3 months ago(0 children)
Colorado
-2 points · 3 months ago

So no, you don't have a source for the claim you just made? I guess we'll just assume this is a Hitchens Razor type situation then.

Why would you trot out a claim about dementia if you're unwilling to support it?

I do happen to know about "age related cognitive decline", I just don't think you do, which is why I asked for a source to back up that assertion.

Comment deleted3 months ago(0 children)
Colorado
0 points · 3 months ago · edited 3 months ago

Then why the hell are you weighing in on it and defending the person who did?! If you're going to pick up an argument from another person, you're responsible for that argument.

Community Details

3.9m

Subscribers

80.8k

Online

/r/Politics is for news and discussion about U.S. politics.

Create Post
Welcome!

Welcome to r/politics! Please read the wiki before participating.

Our Full Rules

Reddiquette

r/politics Rules
1.
Off-topic: Not explicitly about US politics
2.
Out of date: Not published within the last month
3.
Title: Not exact headline. No ALLCAPS
4.
Rehosted: takes majority of content from elsewhere
5.
Content: Not an article/video/sound clip/poll
6.
No paywalls or survey requirements
7.
No incivility, personal attacks, hate speech, etc.
8.
No trolling, novelty accounts, or bots
9.
No solicitation: petitions/volunteer hours/signups
10.
No Hateful Speech
r/politics event calendar

AMA with Matt Bors

July 19, 201810:00

AMA with Hunter Walker

July 24, 201810:00

AMA with Elie Mystal

July 24, 201813:00

with Marc Randazza

July 25, 20188:00

AMA with James Talarico

July 25, 201811:00

AMA with Chris Powell

July 26, 201811:00
Other Resources
Related Communities
r/PoliticalDiscussion

366,641 subscribers

r/Ask_Politics

29,474 subscribers

r/geopolitics

98,541 subscribers

r/ukpolitics

139,717 subscribers

Cookies help us deliver our Services. By using our Services or clicking I agree, you agree to our use of cookies. Learn More.