- Hello and welcome to Today I Learned!
- Rule #1: Submissions must be verifiable.
- Rule #2: No personal opinions, anecdotes, editorializing, or subjective statements.
- Rule #3: No news or recent sources.
- Rule #5: No misleading claims.
- Rule #6: Rephrase your post title if the following are not met:
- Rule #7: No software or website submissions (e.g. "TIL you can click on widgets in WidgetMaker 1.22").
- TIL Karma Shoppe
- Frequent TILs Repost List
Hello and welcome to Today I Learned!
You are loved.
What is TIL?
It's a subreddit for submitting and finding out interesting information about a variety of topics. TIL does not aim for in-depth and serious discussion about a subject, but rather is more interested in a pop-knowledge overview of some minutiae of a field. Basically, if the information that you're trying to convey can't fit in the title of a reddit post then it's probably too nuanced for our snapple bottlecap-esque format!
Do I need to have learned about something today to post it to the subreddit? / The poster obviously didn't learn about the fact today!
"TIL ____" is merely the format of the subreddit. A lot of things on reddit are quite formulaic and this is one of those things. There is nothing wrong with posting interesting content to this subreddit no matter when the poster learned about it!
Can I repost something?
Reposts are sometimes annoying, but we want the community to decide whether or not they want to see something again so individual members have the power to downvote a post. If the downvotes outnumber the upvotes then obviously people don't appreciate your post.
A link was previously submitted, how do I repost it?
Add ?sometexthere to the end of the URL to trick reddit into thinking that it's a new URL. Example: http://www.cnn.com?repost. If you're trying to make a post that contains a link to a tag within the page, you need to put the ?repost part before the #tag part. ie: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Harry_S._Truman?repost#World_War_I
This comment is offensive, can you remove it?
Although we have fairly strict rules about the kind of posts that we want to see on TIL, we try not to moderate the comments in any shape or form! We only remove comments for the follow reasons:
- The comment is off-topic commercial spam
- The comment contains personal information about any public or private figure.
Please remove this post to Wikipedia.
Although we don't want very general posts (ie: TIL about birds) that link to Wikipedia, we have nothing against using Wikipedia as a source! There are many very good reasons for this:
- Wikipedia is actually fairly reliable. Studies have shown that it is about as reliable as other encyclopaedias (e.g.: Britannica) and peer-reviewed scientific publications have attested to Wikipedia's accuracy.
- Wikipedia is editable, but that is a strength -- not a weakness. Try this experiment: go vandalize a page and see how fast it gets reverted. Try it again and see how long until you get banned. Editing a page allows people to add sources or remove dubious unsourceable claims. If the wiki is used as a source for a fake fact, the removal of the "fact" will be grounds for removal of the post as a whole. If some random blog or a website is used as a source for fake fact, there is no simple way to see if the fact is fake or not without the moderators doing additional research or reading through hundreds of comments for someone to point out the flaw.
But this person is karma whoring by link to Wikipedia!!! How can you let this injustice stand?
Once you can convert karma to real currency (or even Bitcoins), we'll review our policy.
Can I be a moderator?
TIL is a pretty big sub and unfortunately the consequences of moderating improperly can be far-reaching (doxing, public witch hunts, etc) so we want any potential moderators to have a firm grasp on the rules before they get the power to remove posts at will. If you want to be a moderator, you can demonstrate that you understand how the subreddit works by using the "message the moderators" feature to send us posts & comments that are candidates for removal. After a month or two of constant reports you will be a very strong contender for becoming a moderator. We have used this recruiting strategy for great results - our last half-dozen moderators have all been picked this way.
Can you please link to my subreddit from your header or sidebar?
Unfortunately... no. We get people offering to "partner up" with us on pretty much a weekly basis and our sidebar is already very busy and cluttered -- as a result, we can't possibly accommodate everyone.
Rule #1: Submissions must be verifiable.
Rationale: Although we aim for pop-knowledge type posts we nevertheless require that the posts are completely factual. TIL has a fairly massive userbase so that last thing we want to do is to contribute to the already egregious amount of misinformation on the internet.
Please link directly to a reliable & reputable source that supports the entire claim in your post title.
What is a reputable source? That depends entirely on the content of the submission -- the more outlandish the claim in the post, the more scholarly and unbiased the source has to be. It's a big plus for your submission if the website that you're linking to has a section for the sources that it used.
Example: TIL That hugging someone to your right side connects your hearts, love instead of fear consciousness Uses some blog called 'Souls talking brain' as a source. Absolutely no proof of this claim at all.
Sources must be in English. It is the common language of the site, and so that is what sources need to be in so that both users and moderators can quickly verify the claims.
What do you mean directly? It means that the only link considered as a source for verifying your claim is the one you link to as your submission's link. Extra links may be provided in the comments, but do not count towards meeting this rule. It needs to support everything in your post title, without personal interpretations. It is not possible for moderators to check outside sources for every submission. The policy that is fair to every submission is requiring one source, since there simply is not enough time to check other sources for every submission.
What is verifiable? This is mostly straight forward. A reliable source has made and supported the claim. However, it is worth mentioning explicitly that "you can't disprove it" is not the same thing as "it's verifiable." Posts to TIL need to be verifiable, not just not easily disproved.
Images alone do not count as valid references.
- Images are easy to doctor.
- Text-in-an-image submissions rarely lists sources.
- Text-in-an-image submissions are usually some sort of email copy-pasta.
- Image hosting can be very fickle
- From previous experience, the vast amount of image-based posts that are submitted have content considerably more suitable for /r/pics, /r/funny, or /r/adviceanimals than for TIL.
As a result, our bot is configured to automatically remove posts linking to an image.
Videos are fine so long as they come from reputable sources (e.g. BBC, discovery, etc).
Basically documentaries are okay, just make sure to either: a) link to the direct time in the video (on youtube right click on the video and select URL w/ current time), b) put the time to your information in the title.
Rule #2: No personal opinions, anecdotes, editorializing, or subjective statements.
Rationale: This is an explicit extension of Rule #1. The explicit explanation is as follows:
TIL focuses on presenting factual statements to its users. Unfortunately, personal opinions are not facts.
Example: TIL that Elephants have a fear of bees (I know that feel, bro). That's nice?
Example: TIL Pope John XII was the biggest badass pope of all time: murdered to gain power, had sex as he pleased, and to top it off, died of a heart attack whilst in bed with a married woman Depends on your definition of badass, I guess
Editorializing is writing a title that attempts to influence the opinion of the readers in some way.
Example: TIL 3 people in the UK die every day waiting for an organ donation. UK Redditors, let's do something about it. Certainly noble, but also not the right place for it.
Example: TIL that Tamerlane was a Turkish ruler whose tomb was discovered by Soviet archeologists in 1941. An inscription in the tomb read "Who ever opens my tomb, shall unleash an invader more terrible than I." Two days later, the Nazis launched Operation Barbarossa and invaded the USSR. Trying to connect the two events as though one beget the other. Obviously just a coincidence.
Personal anecdotes are those posts where the poster talks about something that happened to them or to someone in their family. Sometimes these are great stories, but most of the time they are not verifiable; it is impossible for us to prove if an event happened to the poster or if the poster is the person they claim to be. Furthermore, although the poster may have some cool relatives and the poster finds their life exciting, the mere happenstance of being related to an interesting person is not TIL worthy.
Example: TIL My great great Uncle was James McParland, Liquor Store owner, a Pinkerton Agent, and featured fictionally by A. C. Doyle in The Valley of Fear.. Cool... but what about being related to this guy is interesting to us?
Example: TIL Today I have learned the meaning of letting the past go by. I now accept past events. Good for you!
Subjective statements cannot be objectively backed up.
Example: TIL water in space is much cooler than on earth. Is it really?
Example: TIL that The Reddit community is awesome and that Quora is a waste of time and effort. Can't say I disagree, but that's like your opinion, man.
Rule #3: No news or recent sources.
Rationale for no news: Any recent events are news to everybody hence they're "Today I Learned..." material in the truest sense. Unfortunately, people catch up on recent events at different paces so someone living under a rock may learn of an event a few days or a week after it occurred and then head over to TIL to repost it. However, most everyone else has already seen it so they're faced with a repost. If it's news of a particularly contentious issue, then it'll just bring on a repeat of the flamewars. Furthermore, TIL would become a dumping ground for ALL information -- /r/technology wouldn't be getting posts about some new gizmo, /r/music wouldn't hear about the new albums, /r/gaming wouldn't be getting posts about the newly released games, etc... The rule helps to reduce redundancy among TIL and other subreddits.
Rationale for no recent sources: This rule is meant to cover posts that link to information that was just recently created about events that have occurred some time in the past. The reasoning is that newly created information hasn't been properly "vetted" by domain experts. As a result, the information may not be factual. A two month period is an appropriate amount of time for a contrary viewpoint to emerge and point out any factual inconsistencies in the source.
- This rule does NOT mean that posts that contain links to news articles over 2 months old are not allowed.
Rule #4: Nothing related to recent politics.
Rationale: TIL is not the swiss army knife of reddit subreddits. /r/politics is better suited to that discussion and many of our users have previously expressed a strong desire to keep politics sequestered over there.
For our purposes we consider 8 years to be recent. However, it's the related to part that seems to be most confusing. This means that if it's related to current political issues, or issues from our recent time period, it is not allowed. This includes, but is not limited to, anything about a politician active in that time. For example, a post about something that Obama did 20 years ago would be removed, because it is related to a current politician, this will apply even after he is no longer the president, as he will still have been active in the "recent" period. This rule is also not limited to political issues in the U.S.; topics relating to politics of other nations are not allowed either.
It also means posts about things older than 8 years that relate to current or recent politics are also banned. For example, marijuana legalization is a current political topic, with legalization efforts ongoing in many states. As a result, legalization is a banned topic, even if the legalization point you want to reference is older than 8 years. It may be helpful to think of the 8 years as setting a time limit on how long before a banned topic becomes unbanned after no longer being political. It does not mean that political events over 8 years old are automatically okay.
What are some examples of recent political topics?
- Anything torture
- Anything about police misconduct
- Anything related to terrorism/War in the Middle East
- NSA and other US spying
- Marijuana legalization
- Pro/Anti-Vaccination topics
- Wage issues
- Gender issues
- 2008/2012 American Election. They may be over, but they're still political.
- Gun control
- Climate change
- Anything Barack Obama
- Anything George W. Bush
- Anything Bill Clinton because he continues to be a highly publicly visible political figure -- campaigning for Hillary, etc.
- Ditto for Hillary Clinton
- 2016 American Election
- Government Spending
- Health Care issues
- Donald Trump
The above examples are not an exhaustive list of all political topics which are not allowed on TodayILearned. Other topics not listed here may still be removed for being political in nature.
Rule #5: No misleading claims.
Posts that omit essential information, or present unrelated facts in a way that suggest a connection will be removed.
Rule #6: Rephrase your post title if the following are not met:
- a. Titles must begin with "TIL ..."
- b. Make them descriptive, concise and specific (e.g. not "TIL something interesting about bacon").
e.g.: TIL About Humanity
- c. Titles must be able to stand on their own without requiring readers to click on a link. Starting your title with a why/what/who/where/how modifier should be unnecessary.
- d. "TIL about ..." and other broad posts don't belong on TIL. Try /r/Wikipedia, etc. instead, or be more specific (and avoid the word "about"). This also includes posts like "TIL X exists" or "TIL Y is a thing."
- e. "TIL how to ..." posts belong on /r/HowTo.
Rule #7: No software or website submissions (e.g. "TIL you can click on widgets in WidgetMaker 1.22").
What are some examples?
You can click/press a button on youtube to make it shake/tilt
Wikipedia has a list of ________
This website has this thing for sale
This website exists
This includes posts about aspects of Reddit as well.
TIL Karma Shoppe
(Or: what are those yellow/golden numbers near some people's names anyway?)
So.. we all know that internet points are worthless... or are they?
Are you interested in making TIL a better place? Are you someone who cannot stand to see inaccurate TIL posts? You're not alone! Just send the moderators a message and include a link to the submission with a short explanation detailing why a post is inaccurate or which rule it breaks.
Frequent TILs Repost List
As of June, 2016
Submit new comments in this thread
As of April, 2016
Based on this thread [Locked as of June, 2016]
Posts on this list will be removed.
*Steve Buscemi did 9/11
*Leonardo DiCaprio cut his hand in Django Unchained
*Guys cut their balls off to watch March Madness
*Seth Macfarlane missed a flight on 9/11
*Albert Einstein turned down the offer of being President of Israel
*TIL Napoleon's height was not below average
*Hitler did methamphetamine during the war
*The world's deadliest sniper in history
*OJ Simpson supposed to be the Terminator
*Mozart and scatological humor
*Mark Wahlberg is a violent racist
*tree of tenere
*werner herzog saved joauquin phoenix
*Bill Morgan lottery winner
*Mel Blanc was in a coma and was only woken up by the doctor referring to him as Bugs Bunny
*Phantom Of Heilbronn
*Heil Honey I'm Home
*Mad Jack/John Churchill
*Kinder Eggs are illegal in America
*Buetooth King Harald Runes H B
*TIL that Sweden Blood Bank Texts Donors To Notify Them Whenever Their Blood Helps Save A Life
*TIL when Monty Python started uploading their comedy skits to YouTube so they could be watched legally for free, their DVD sales went up by 16,000%
*John Cena has granted more than 400 makeawish
*Girl saved people from tsunami after learning signs in high school
*TIL a contestant on Who wants to be a millionaire phoned his dad
*Thomas Baker killed 8 men with 8 bullets
*Mystery Dum dum flavour
*Penguins have knees
*There's a giant reservoir of xxxx in space
*Lyndon B Johnson amphibious car
*Fanta invented by/for Nazis
*MLB uses a specific type of mud
*The Christmas Truce of 1914
*TIL that MSG is generally accepted as harmless
*Knuckle-cracking Nobel Prize
*Tsutomu Yamaguchi was in Hiroshima for work
*Soccer match between Barbados and Grenada
*Pablo Escabar rubber bands/pet hippos
*Concerned about the number of cobras in Delhi, British colonial officials created a bounty
*The first country to recognize the US as an independent country was Morocco
*UK has a Chief Mouser position
*The damaged kidneys are left in your body when you get a kidney transplant
*The man who invented the Frisbee was cremated and made into Frisbees after he died
*Hans Island war between Canada and Denmark
*Volleyball washed ashore during screenwriter's isolation for "cast away"
*Sun Chips made environmentally friendly bags that were very noisy
*Alfred Nobel Dynamite
*Buffalo buffalo...buffalo is a sentence.
*Lone star tick induces a red meat allergy.
*Michael Jackson worked on the music for Sonic the Hedgehog 3
*Mao ordered all sparrows killed
*61 year old potato farmer won the inaugural Westfield Sydney to Melbourne Ultramarathon
*The Wachowski sisters
*National Animal of Scotland is a unicorn
*Oklahoma state vegetable is the watermelon fruit
*Domino's Pizza discontinued use of the "Noid" character
*Mike the headless chicken
*Superman couldn't fly originally
*Dr. Ruth was a sniper
*Origin of Monopoly game
*Show must go on/Queen
*Marvel blue ear
*Lego is the largest tire manufacturer by volume
*There's a Ned Flanders themed metal band called "Okily Dokily"
*Cows are fed candy/Skittles.
*Waffle House Index and FEMA.
*U.S. 27th Amendment took over 200 years to be ratified
*only one person alive born in 19th century
*town in Florida seceded and immediately applied for foreign aid
*James Harrison's blood and Rhesus disease
* Hiroo Onoda, last Japanese holdout from WWII
* Good Will Hunting gay blow job scene to check if film execs read the script
* Anything Elon Musk related
* White House solar panels removed
* Kitkats are considered lucky in Japan
* Processed meats are carcinogens
* Kellogg's Corn Flakes were created to deter masturbation
revision by Kylde— view source